Movie Reviews By Reviewer Type –
All Critics Top Critics All Audience
Prev Next It gets as many things wrong as it does right.ultimately, season two does enough to justify its existence and you’ll likely binge-watch it faster than the first. Full Review | May 18, 2021 13 Reasons Why season two is uncomfortable but remarkable viewing. Full Review | Apr 14, 2020 There is not nearly enough hope, for the characters or the audience. Full Review | Jan 15, 2019 With the exception of a solid performance again by the talented Dylan Minnette, the Brian Yorkey-showrun adaptation has run out of gas and source material. Full Review | Dec 29, 2018 While the show is explicit, and not everyone’s cup of tea, I do believe that if you have the mindset to look beyond the obscenities, you’d understand that it’s story that needs to be told. Full Review | Nov 8, 2018 There was no good reason to bring 13 Reasons Why back for a second season. Full Review | Oct 31, 2018 This new season is frustrating at times, and silly during much of its run, but there are still scenes of caring friendship, of tentative romance or raw loneliness that make up for some of the trite and forced plot developments. Full Review | Original Score: C+ | Oct 23, 2018 As the show evolves from a mystery and teen drama into a courtroom drama, it quickly loses its footing. The result is an inessential season of TV that revels in misery. Full Review | Original Score: 1.5/4 | Oct 10, 2018 Because the first season covered the entire novel this new batch of episodes attempt to keep the story going. There’s one fatal flaw: It really is just rewinding itself, going over everything that happened previously but with added twists. Full Review | Aug 26, 2018 13 Reasons Why will never spell out its life lessons for us, but for the sake of its younger viewers and my sanity, its after-show starkly does. Full Review | Aug 24, 2018 Is it possible to keep stretching gum? Full Review | Jun 29, 2018 If Season 2 was about healing and about letting go,. then maybe the show should follow its own themes and move on. Full Review | Original Score: 2.5/5 | Jun 15, 2018 A frank, bold, important look at modern teenage life. But, as with most series, it isn’t for everyone. Full Review | Jun 14, 2018 13 Reasons Why lacks the nuance essential to navigating this terrain. Full Review | Jun 12, 2018 As with the first season, 13 Reasons Why is not an easy, breezy Saturday night binge but there’s something addictive about it, that is until you remember teen angst has a limited shelf life. Full Review | Jun 7, 2018 The second season feels more like dealing with the aftermath of the first season’s criticism, while lacking a true narrative of its own. Full Review | Jun 6, 2018 The second season is an even more problematic dumpster fire. Like the kind of dumpster fire that can spread rapidly to other buildings and really make a giant, fiery mess of things. Full Review | May 25, 2018 13 Reasons Why’s first season had its issues, but its second season is nearly unwatchable. Full Review | May 25, 2018 Remains ridiculously gratuitous and irresponsible. It is bleak and depressing, scarringly graphic and stupidly glamorising in its treatment of guns and ideas of vengeance. Full Review | May 25, 2018 The second season of Netflix’s controversial teen drama 13 Reasons Why has fans asking a lot of questions. Full Review | May 25, 2018 Prev Next Do you think we mischaracterized a critic’s review?
What is the point of season 2 of 13 Reasons Why?
Here’s How “13 Reasons Why” Season 2 Ended Trigger Warning: This post contains language about sexual assault, suicidal ideation, gun violence, and substance use that some readers may find disturbing. season 2 debuted on May 18. The of the show followed a high school student named Clay Jensen () who is tasked with following a series of tapes left to his classmates by a girl named Hannah Baker (), after she died by suicide.
The adaptation of the novel by Jay Asher and executive produced by sparked a major conversation when it debuted in March 2017. While some applauded the series for putting a spotlight on various taboo subjects, it also received and mental health experts for its portrayals of suicide, sexual assault, bullying, and substance use.
The second season of the Netflix series continued to explore those topics by following Liberty High students as they deal with the aftermath of Hannah’s death — as well as their own traumas — and try to move on with their lives. The primary focus is the Bakers’ (Kate Walsh and Brian d’Arcy James) lawsuit against the school, which claims Liberty took a blind eye to the bullying Hannah faced and failed to respond to warning signs of her suicidal ideation.
Meanwhile, Clay and his classmates have another mystery to solve when mysterious Polaroid pictures surface that suggest (spoiler alert) the school’s baseball team is responsible for serial sexual assaults. The show has also implemented including Katherine, Dylan,, and Justin Prentice out of character, some fans also created other resources, including so that potential viewers aren’t as blindsided by the intentionally difficult subject matter.
Yet some viewers are still calling out the new installment, arguing that some of the storylines in season 2 are too “disturbing” to watch. The show’s creator, Brian Yorkey, has pointing out that “When we talk about something being ‘disgusting’ or hard to watch, often that means we are attaching shame to the experience.
We would rather not be confronted with it. We would rather it stay out of our consciousness. This is why these kinds of assaults are underreported. This is why victims have a hard time seeking help. We believe that talking about it is so much better than silence.” However, it appears that the creative team behind the show is taking measures to listen to viewers.
During July 2019, Netflix announced that it would be, premieres on August 23, 2019, and there are also some major changes following a time jump. The biggest? That Bryce Walker is dead and nobody knows who killed him. The latest installment will surely have plenty more twists and turns.
- Whether you quickly watched 13 Reasons Why season 2 the first weekend it dropped, simply want to know how the second installment ended, or need a refresher of how everything went down, we have you covered.
- Here’s a recap of how things went down at the end of the second season to bring you up to speed where the show’s characters stand.
Warning: Spoilers ahead.
Who was messing with everyone in 13 Reasons Why season 2?
What’s Beecher’s story? – Not much is really known about Beecher before episode six. As one of the players on the football team, he is really close to his teammates, especially Diego. Everyone originally believed that he was working with the rest of the team and Diego to trick the whole class in the scavenger hunt.
- However, after Diego was found by Jessica, Charlie, and Justin in the abandoned cabin, he revealed that he is actually looking for Beecher and that someone is also messing with the football team.
- Shortly after, Beecher is thrown inside of the cabin, tied up and without his pants on.
- This helped prove to the rest of the group that the football team isn’t behind the weird and creepy stuff that’s going on.
When trying to figure out who or what is behind the creepy kidnappings and everything that is going on, Beecher believes that it’s the infamous ghost of Burnham Woods. When Zach walks into the cabin, Beecher and the rest of the football guys (minus Charlie) end up running out before the mysterious figure tries to go after them again.
Is 13 Reasons Why season 3 good?
Movie Reviews By Reviewer Type –
All Critics Top Critics All Audience
Prev Next It just feels incredibly exploitative. If you want to have a show that helps you, go elsewhere. Full Review | Jul 15, 2020 Season 3 is not as strong as its previous seasons, but that does not make it any less relevant. Full Review | Sep 25, 2019 Every season, the number of women in the cast shrinks, and they’re replaced with more tortured boys in increasingly violent situations.It’s just more blatant about it now. Full Review | Sep 4, 2019 Every time this show almost does something good it just veers off for the lazy sophomoric treatise instead. It’s exhausting and it’s unpleasant and it’s often dangerous, and at this point, there is no reason why it should still be around. Full Review | Original Score: 1/5 | Sep 3, 2019 This strange insistence on moralizing teen pain, while also presenting completely amoral storylines, makes season three such a frustrating watch. Full Review | Aug 30, 2019 If “13 Reasons Why” wasn’t such a well-viewed show, we could ignore it as just another bad piece of television. Full Review | Original Score: D- | Aug 29, 2019 13 Reasons Why tried to re-brand itself in its third season, but it’s still over the top and ridiculous. Full Review | Aug 29, 2019 What I’m really saying is that the third season of 13 Reasons Why is a ridiculous, maddening, overlong example of Peak TV-era television that doesn’t know how to quit when it’s ahead. Full Review | Aug 28, 2019 13 Reasons Why repeatedly indulges in the “angry young man” trope, but Season 3 sees Clay become more of an impediment to his own benevolence than ever. Full Review | Aug 28, 2019 Maybe instead of “keeping an eye on Tyler” at all times, the students could instead find him some professional help. Full Review | Aug 28, 2019 By cluttering its plot with preposterous drama even as it strains for uplift, or at least some greater meaning, the series undermines its own intention-and winds up making itself useful to no one in particular. Full Review | Aug 27, 2019 Television series must evolve to stay interesting, but it is telling that a drama predicated on an unusual storytelling angle chose strip back to basics, mostly for the sake of staying alive. Full Review | Aug 26, 2019 Left with no excuse to recycle the tragic story of Hannah Baker, this third outing spins a whole new narrative that plays like a bad teen melodrama. Full Review | Aug 26, 2019 Season three returns the show to top form, a narrative as delectable as it is irresponsible. Full Review | Aug 26, 2019 It’s not that shows can’t evolve, but the whole conceit of 13 Reasons Why has been thrown away in favor of a luridly macabre soap opera, starring a cast of actors clearly outgrowing their parts. Full Review | Aug 23, 2019,On 13 Reasons Why, yet again, it seems to exist as a sensationalized plot device, masked by a discourse about tackling serious issues that, with this show, still seems to amount to all talk and no value. Full Review | Aug 23, 2019 Everything is melodramatic, everyone feels everything so deeply, and it’s utterly exhausting. Full Review | Aug 23, 2019 The problem here is how much misery will these teenagers have to endure just to come of age? Full Review | Aug 23, 2019 Prev Next Do you think we mischaracterized a critic’s review?
What is the most watched episode of 13 Reasons Why?
Tape 7, Side A (9.2) – 
The season 1 finale is the show’s top-rated episode, All of the stories Hannah has recounted in the tapes culminate in one final decision. By this point, characters and viewers alike already know what her choice is, but the moment still comes as a shock.
- After a failed attempt to seek help from Mr.
- Porter, Hannah decides that she has no other options left.
- She goes home, records the tapes, sends them to Tony, and kills herself.
- The graphic scene has since been removed from Netflix’s cut.
- Nine out of ten of the best episodes are from season 1, probably because it has the most refined focus and original concept of the four seasons.
NEXT: 13 Reasons Why: MBTI® of the Main Characters
Did they remove the bathtub scene in 13 Reasons Why?
Inside the decision to edit the controversial series 
The depiction of Hannah’s death was the aspect of the show that most troubled many experts, who argued it flouted long-standing media guidelines for portraying suicide. (Netflix) If you are having thoughts of suicide, please know that you are not alone.
- If you are in danger of acting on suicidal thoughts, call 911.
- For support and resources, call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 800-273-8255 or text 741-741 for the Crisis Text Line.
- When the first season of the Netflix teen drama 13 Reasons Why was released, in March 2017, the instantaneous clamor of viewers reacting to it online was followed by responses from mental-health experts expressing concerns about the show’s portrayal of suicide.
The series, based on a young-adult book of the same name by Jay Asher, is framed around one teenager’s decision to end her own life, and the various people she sees as having contributed to her crisis. In the book, the act of the central character Hannah’s suicide is mentioned only fleetingly.
- In the series, it was portrayed in brutal, explicit detail over several minutes.
- Suicide-prevention advocates objected to a number of the show’s elements, ranging from the perceived glorification of Hannah as a romantic heroine to the uselessness of the adults around her.
- But the depiction of Hannah’s death was the aspect of the show that most troubled many experts, who argued it flouted long-standing media guidelines for portraying suicide, and could even lead to a potential contagion effect among teenage viewers.
More than two years later, Netflix announced on Tuesday that it made the decision to cut that scene entirely. In a newly edited version of the Season 1 finale that replaced the old version, Hannah (played by Katherine Langford) looks at her reflection in the bathroom mirror.
The next immediate shot is of her mother, Olivia (Kate Walsh), discovering her body. The cut is seamless, and solemn. A representative for Netflix declined my request for an interview with 13 Reasons Why ‘s showrunner, Brian Yorkey, or other producers. In a public statement, Yorkey said: Our creative intent in portraying the ugly, painful reality of suicide in such graphic detail in Season 1 was to tell the truth about the horror of such an act, and make sure no one would ever wish to emulate it.
But as we ready to launch Season 3, we have heard concerns about the scene from Dr. Christine Moutier at the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention and others, and have agreed with Netflix to re-edit it. No one scene is more important than the life of the show, and its message that we must take better care of each other.
We believe this edit will help the show do the most good for the most people while mitigating any risk for especially vulnerable young viewers. That the decision to reedit the episode took two years to finalize speaks to how intense the discussions were among 13 Reasons Why ‘s creative team over the specific treatment of suicide in the show’s first season.
(Season 2 debuted in 2018; a third season is expected to be released this summer.) Nic Sheff, one of the writers on the show, originally wrote an op-ed for Vanity Fair in 2017 arguing that the graphic detail of Hannah’s death was necessary, because the horror of the scene should help dissuade viewers from copying her.
- Dr. Helen Hsu, a clinical psychologist consulted by Netflix prior to the show’s release, told me that year that the show’s creators wanted to avoid romanticizing suicide by suggesting that it could ever be a serene or peaceful act.
- Following the show’s release, its producers monitored reactions to the series online, and documented a wide range of responses.
“I think what they felt,” Moutier told me, “is that they were hearing very mixed messages.” Some viewers even in recent weeks have responded positively to the portrayal of Hannah’s death for how honestly and unflinchingly it showed the violence of ending one’s life.
- The conclusion from almost all mental-health experts, though, was that such a graphic scene represented more risk than it did reward. Dr.
- Dan Reidenberg, the executive director of Suicide Awareness Voices of Education, was consulted by Netflix before the first season debuted, and was reportedly so troubled by its messaging that he advised them not to release it,
“Within the suicide-prevention field, there is very solid consensus around graphic portrayals needing to be avoided because of the risk of contagion,” Moutier said. She was first consulted by Netflix after the show’s release in 2017 regarding the addition of more informational content surrounding 13 Reasons Why.
She helped develop the website 13ReasonsWhy.info, which is a resource for parents and educators regarding suicide prevention and mental health; the warning cards Netflix added to the beginning of episodes; and the series of short videos made by actors in the show encouraging viewers to seek help if they need it.
When Moutier and the AFSP first started working with Netflix, she assumed it was too late for any of the show’s content to be tweaked or edited. Her goal was simply to make sure that the series was making supplementary information available to anyone who might need it.
Prior to the release of the third season of 13 Reasons Why, though, the show’s creators finally came around to the idea that the portrayal of Hannah’s death might be unnecessarily damaging, and started to consult Moutier on its potential removal. In the two years since the show first debuted, several studies had emerged analyzing a possible spike in suicide attempts and suicidal ideation among young people that accompanied its release.
The team behind 13 Reasons Why, Moutier said, paid attention to all these studies and were concerned about their results. Netflix also commissioned its own study, conducted by Northwestern University, which found that viewers had increased empathy for others after watching the series, and were more likely to discuss mental-health issues with others.
- The Netflix study didn’t include questions about suicidal ideation or attempts.) One study from the University of Pennsylvania found that viewers who watched the show’s second season were less likely to consider harming themselves.
- The mixed results, Moutier told me, speak to the fact that different people can have very different responses to the same cultural product.
“Anything short of a well-done educational documentary is probably going to have a very heterogeneous level of impact,” she said. In the end, after much discussion, Yorkey and his team decided that the specific scene of Hannah’s death was too potentially risky to justify its continued inclusion, particularly given the fact that the third season’s release would inevitably bring new young viewers to the show.
- Even if just lives on the platform, you have a group of children who are coming of age to start watching it from the beginning,” Moutier said.
- She emphasized that the decision to cut the scene is “a big deal.” Part of the reason it was such a difficult one to make is because storytellers inevitably find their desire to create bold, provocative drama in tension with the most responsible ways of creating fiction.
“The instincts that create the most highly engaging entertainment tend to be highly dramatic, fast-moving, sensational, and emotional,” Moutier said. “And some of that absolutely comes into conflict with issues of suicide contagion.” A product like 13 Reasons Why, which became a viral hit faster than its creators had ever anticipated, which is being heavily watched by young viewers, and which lives on a platform that encourages immersive consumption, also bears more risk than a show airing weekly on a national network or on cable.
- Moutier said that she hadn’t been consulted on the content of the show’s upcoming third season.) That’s not to say that TV shows or films can’t marry responsible storytelling with narrative excellence.
- Moutier cited the 2012 David O.
- Russell movie Silver Linings Playbook as a work that treated mental-health issues with thoughtfulness and nuance, as well as the former Netflix sitcom One Day at a Time, which was recently picked up for a fourth season by Pop TV,
As younger generations—who stigmatize mental-health struggles less than their elders—grow up, she expects solicitous portrayal of topics like suicide, depression, bullying, and assault to increase in number. “I do have a lot of hope,” she said, “that things are going to keep trending in that direction.”
Did they remove the death scene in 13 Reasons Why?
Image source, Netflix Image caption, Katherine Langford plays Hannah Baker in the Netflix drama A controversial scene in Netflix drama 13 Reasons Why in which a teenage girl kills herself has been removed, two years after it first appeared. Netflix said the decision had been made “on the advice of medical experts”.
- The first series of the show featured a graphic depiction of Hannah (Katherine Langford) taking her own life.
- The version now hosted on the streaming site omits this three-minute scene and goes directly to a later scene in which her body is discovered.
- Samaritans said it “welcomed” Netflix’s decision and that it had been working with the streaming service’s UK team “to provide advice on the safe portrayal of suicide”.
“While covering difficult topics in drama can help to increase understanding and encourage people to seek help, it’s important this is done in a responsible way,” said Lorna Fraser from the charity’s media advisory service. Image source, Netflix Image caption, Dylan Minnette plays Clay Jensen, the show’s lead character Netflix said it had been “mindful about the ongoing debate around the show”, the third season of which premieres later this year.
- Dr Christine Moutier, chief medical officer at the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, is cited as one of the experts consulted.
- When 13 Reasons Why launched in 2017, it was praised by some for promoting awareness of such issues as rape, bullying and self-harm.
- But concerns were also raised that it glamorised suicide and went into too much detail about how the Hannah character killed herself.
Writing on Twitter, producer Brian Yorkey said the show had originally portrayed the “ugly, painful reality of suicide in such graphic detail make sure no one would ever wish to emulate it”. Yet he said concerns voiced by Dr Moutier and others had prompted a rethink.
Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Producer Brian Yorkey said the show wanted to “tell the truth” about suicide “No one scene is more important than the life of the show, and its message that we must take better care of each other,” he said. “We believe this edit will help the show do the most good for the most people while mitigating any risk for especially vulnerable young viewers.” Based on the 2007 novel by Jay Asher, 13 Reasons Why tells of a high school student who finds out why his friend killed herself through a box of cassette tapes she recorded before her death.
If you have been affected by issues raised in this article help and support is available via the BBC Action Line,
Did Alex go to jail for killing Bryce?
Katherine Langford as Hannah Baker Warning: This post contains major plot points from the third season of 13 Reasons Why, DO NOT READ unless you want to have the season’s mystery spoiled for you. Ever since the moment that Netflix released the first trailer for 13 Reasons Why ‘s third season, we’ve known one thing: Someone killed Bryce Walker.
Throughout the entirety of the season —13 episodes, to be exact—the students of Liberty High worked together to try to figure out who was responsible. All signs pointed to the night of the Homecoming game, which was played between Liberty and Hillcrest, A.K.A Bryce’s new school. A fight broke out. Zach was carried off the field with a busted knee.
Everyone else walked away with black eyes and bruises. But Bryce walked away never to be seen again. At least not by everyone. The question of the season was this: What happened between the Homecoming game and Bryce’s body washing up? And before we reveal the answer, let us once again say this: THIS IS A MAJOR SPOILER.
- Only scroll if you want all the answers Okay, here’s how it went down: Before the Homecoming game started, Bryce asked if Jessica would meet him after.
- He had something he wanted to give to her.
- But after Bryce tore up Zach’s knee in the fight, it was Zach who followed Bryce out to the docks where he was supposed to meet Jess.
There, Zach fought Bryce, breaking one of his legs and one of his arms in the process. But Zach didn’t kill Bryce. He simply left him with no way to get home (or even get up). After Zach left, Jessica and Alex showed up. (She brought Alex for protection.) Bryce gave her a tape he’d made admitting to all of the rapes he’d committed and apologizing for the damage he’d done.
- But just as Jess and Alex started to leave, Bryce asked if they could help him get up.
- Alex started to help Bryce walk, but then Alex realized just how much hurt Bryce had caused all of them.
- At that moment, Alex shoved him into the water where Bryce would go on to drown.
- And yet, Alex didn’t go to jail for his crime.
Instead, everyone agreed to place the blame on Monty, who was already in jail—and it turns out had already been killed in jail—for sexually assaulting Tyler in season 2, So not only did Alex kill Bryce, but he got away with it. Related content: Katherine Langford as Hannah Baker 13 Reasons Why Based on the 2007 novel by Jay Asher, the Netflix drama follows a teen named Clay who attempts to figure out what led his classmate and crush Hannah to take her own life.
| type |
TV Show |
| seasons |
4 |
| rating | |
| genre |
Drama Mystery |
| creator |
Brian Yorkey |
| network |
Netflix |
| stream service |
Netflix |
What did Tony do to Hannah?
Season 1 – When Clay came out of school, Tony offered to give him a ride home. Clay accepted the offer and got inside the car. They rode through the neighborhood and Tony finally reached Clay’s house. He bid him goodbye and headed for his front door as Tony drove away.
- After Clay discovered the tapes of the late Hannah Baker in the front of the door, he cycled over to Tony’s house to borrow a cassette player so he could listen to the tapes, after his one got broken back home.
- Tony and his dad were preoccupied with fixing Tony’s old Mustang, so Clay stole the Walkman and made an excuse that his mother was cooking dinner and that he needed to be home.
Later that day, at Eisenhower Park while Clay was listening to Tape 1, Side A on the Walkman, Tony approached him, in an attempt to hide the Walkman, Clay removed the earplugs from his ear and hid the Walkman, However, Tony knew that he’d stolen his Walkman and confronted him.
- Clay told him that it was his and asked to borrow it in embarrassment.
- Tony, seeming honest enough, said it was no sweat, and told him to be careful while riding his bike though, since he’d fallen off the bike earlier.
- He bid him goodbye and walked towards his car, after giving hints that he knew about Hannah’s tapes,
The next day, after listening to the tapes all night, Clay approached Tony at the school cafeteria. Clay was frustrated with Tony concerning the tapes. He asked if Tony took part in helping Hannah make the tapes. Tony wasn’t on the tapes and he also took no part in the making of the tapes.
After bombarding Tony with questions, Tony just replied, “Listen to the tapes, Clay” and that Hannah wanted it done like that. Clay wasn’t satisfied with the answer. He told him what if he didn’t want to listen to the tapes, to which Tony replied that it would only get worse. After school, Zach and Marcus offered Clay a ride to Bryce’s.
Tony asked Clay if he’s okay and told the guys to leave, which they did. Tony later joined Clay at Monet’s, where they talked about the tapes. Tony asked Clay why he’s taking a long time to listen to the tapes; Clay explained that it’s because he finds it hard to hear Hannah’s voice.
Tony received a call from Mrs. Baker, who had found hot-or-not list and wanted to learn more about it. From across the street, Clay watched Tony hug Mrs. Baker and enter her house. Tony and Mrs. Baker met up at Monet’s, seemingly to discuss the list. Mrs. Baker asked Tony about Clay; Tony told her that he doesn’t know what his relationship with Hannah was like.
When the jocks forced Clay to compete against Alex in a drinking competition, Tony watched it with disgust. Clay confronted Tony about not helping him, which resulted in an argument and Tony telling Clay that if he doesn’t trust him, he can’t help. Tony drove off and Clay chased him on his bike until he saw Tony and his brothers beating up a man.
- At the Jensen Residence, Mrs.
- Jensen had invited Tony over for dinner after talking to his dad at a parent meeting.
- When asked about their ‘history project’, which is a lie Clay told his Dad about the tapes, Clay mentioned that he thinks he’s done with the ‘project’.
- Tony tried to convince Clay that it’s important to continue listening.
A flashback shows that Tony was the deejay at the Winter Formal, After the dance, he helped Hannah with her car and gave her a tape of The Night We Met, the song she and Clay danced to that night. Clay gave Tony the tapes, saying that he can’t listen and if Tony can tell him the reason he’s on the tapes.
- Instead, Tony took Clay to a big rock where they started rock climbing.
- On top of the rock, Tony revealed to Clay that Hannah trusted Tony with the tapes because he’s the only guy at school who didn’t harass her.
- He also told Clay that the day Hannah died, she dropped off the tapes at his door.
- He thought it wasn’t important and he didn’t want to deal with her ‘drama’, so he didn’t immediately pick up the box.
When he started listening to the first tape, he tried to call the Bakers and rushed to Hannah’s house, but it was too late. He now felt the responsibility to make sure everyone listens to the tapes. After listening to tape 9, Clay confronted Tony at the garage about doing nothing after having listened to it and not being more upset about everything.
- Tony told Clay that he isn’t doing it for Hannah and Clay doesn’t know the whole story yet.
- Out of anger, Clay started pushing Tony and throwing stuff around.
- Tony then iced Clay’s leg and told Clay that he’ll always help him.
- Tony found Clay at the Eisenhower Park and joined him, for the reason that Clay was about to listen to his tape.
Clay told him he can’t do it and asked if he killed Hannah. Tony tried to dodge the question by saying everyone let her down and she killed herself, but then told Clay that he did kill Hannah. Tony stayed with Clay and drove him around while he listened to his tape, because he didn’t know what’s going to happen if Clay heard Hannah’s truth.
They took a break from listening to get some food at Monet’s before driving to a spot where Clay can continue listening to the tape. After hearing the part of the tape where Clay left the bedroom when Hannah told him to, Clay started blaming himself and broke down. Tony pulled Clay into a hug and drove him home, making him promise not to do anything stupid.
Clay and Tony met up at school, where Tony gave Clay a tape recorder and asked Clay why he had asked for this. Clay pointed out that if Bryce gets the tapes, he won’t pass them on to the last tape subject and said he has a plan. At the Baker’s store, Mrs.
- Baker confronted Tony about a paper with names she found that also has Tony’s name on it.
- Tony pretended to not know what the paper means, which Mrs.
- Baker didn’t believe.
- Tony’s boyfriend Brad confronted Tony about introducing him as his ‘friend’ and asked him about what’s going on.
- Tony started telling Brad about Hannah and broke down as he isn’t sure if he’s doing the right thing by keeping her secrets.
A flashback shows that Tony had given Hannah a tape recorder she had asked for. Tony asked what she needed it for; Hannah told him it was for some “stupid thing”. Tony stopped by Clay’s house, where Clay played Tony Bryce’s confession. Tony commented that the tape would blow up the world, to which Clay replied that it’s exactly what they should do.
Why did Hannah Baker blame Clay?
13 Reasons Why sees Hannah Baker call out those that contributed to her suicide – but she also leaves a tape for Clay. We break down why that was. 
Netflix’s 13 Reasons Why saw Hannah Baker posthumously confront those who contributed to her eventual suicide, but she also left a tape for her friend, Clay Jensen – here’s why. Developed by Brian Yorkey – with Selena Gomez, previously eyed for a film adaptation, now acting as an executive producer – 13 Reasons Why season 1 premiered in its entirety in early 2017.
Despite telling a largely self-contained story, it was renewed for three subsequent seasons in the wake of season 1’s positive reviews and surging popularity. Ultimately starring Katherine Langford as Hannah Baker, 13 Reasons Why picked up in the aftermath of the character taking her own life. In the middle of his grief, Clay received a set of labeled cassette tapes.
As he began to listen to them, he realized that they served as an audio suicide note. Furthermore, it became clear that each tape referred to a specific person and event – each deepening her depression and pushing her ever closer to her fateful decision.
Depicted through flashbacks, Hannah’s titular 13 reasons included the majority of the show’s main characters and explored such serious topics as bullying, harassment, and sexual assault. The mere fact Clay received the tapes meant that he was also included on the list. That fact was highlighted throughout the season – adding another element of mystery to proceedings.
The answer was ultimately revealed during 13 Reasons Why season 1, episode 11, “Tape 6, Side A”. Hannah told the story of the time she and Clay went to a party together. There, they finally gave in to their feelings and almost turned their friendship into something more.
Unfortunately, Hannah broke down and ultimately yelled at Clay to leave. According to Hannah, she had secretly wanted Clay to stay and console her. Despite that, she didn’t blame Clay for doing merely as she outwardly demanded. Hannah went on to say that Clay didn’t actually belong on the list at all. However, he needed to be there as he was a part of her story.
Plus, she wanted him to hear her side – which he may not have, had the tapes merely gone through the others. 
That would have been especially true had they made it to Bryce Walker. The tape directly after Clay’s own was made for Bryce – who had raped Hannah at a separate party sometime later. Everybody on the list before Clay worked eagerly to bury the tapes and everything detailed on them.
- Were Bryce to have come into possession of them at that point, the intimidation and general effort made to that end would have likely been more successful.
- After all, Bryce and his family were notably wealthy and had access to considerable resources.
- Though 13 Reasons Why tried to humanize Bryce in season 3, he was originally depicted as an unrepentant monster.
As such, he would’ve had little trouble making ruthlessly sure Hannah’s story went away or was otherwise discredited early. By including Clay on the list, Hannah showed remarkable foresight even amid her depression and ensured that the story would end in the right hands.
- In this case, it was Clay bypassing Bryce to give the tapes to Mr.
- Porter and spurring Tony Padilla to give a digital copy to Hannah’s parents.
- Clay being on the tapes also set up a reflection of the painful and equally traumatic effects a person’s suicide can have on those left behind.
- Clay’s sense of guilt of what he had possibly done to Hannah weighed heavily on him in the lead up to his tape.
Though Hannah told him he’d done nothing wrong, Clay’s guilt only intensified further – to the point that he almost killed himself too. Those very realistic feelings twisted his mind and manifested in several (often troubling) ways across the subsequent seasons – until, unlike Hannah, he was seemingly able to put those demons to rest in the 13 Reasons Why series finale,
Is season 4 of 13 Reasons Why worth watching?
The final season reclaims only crumbs of that sensibility. There’s no revenge story here; no real mystery; and no one gets their comeuppance. It drifts until the shocking death, which erases most of the storyline that came before it, or at least reduces it to an afterthought.
Which season is better on 13 Reasons Why?
Season 1: 80% – 
By far the most focussed season, the first installment of 13 Reasons Why is all about Clay slowly learning why Hannah decided to commit suicide. Along the way, Clay doesn’t just learn about Hannah, but about Jessica, Alex, Justin, Tyler, and several others.
Why is 13 Reasons Why bad after season 1?
I read Jay Asher’s 13 Reasons Why not long after it was originally published in 2007. The story about a teenage girl who dies by suicide and leaves behind 13 tapes with her 13 reasons for taking her life, was a very heavy one, but one that I felt OK reading.
- I was in my early 20s at the time, older than the main character Hannah Baker, but I couldn’t help but feel her pain of wanting to make friends and fall in love and be normal, only to have things constantly knock her down.
- It was a story with a beginning, a middle, and an end, and I was curious to see how Netflix would handle the adaptation when the story first dropped on the streamer in 2017.
Katherine Langford took on the role of Hannah and did her justice. Alongside Dylan Minnette as the other main character Clay Jensen, Langford made me feel Hannah’s pain in a way that you can’t always get in a book. And though the show was incredibly graphic — including rape and suicide in great detail — it did the book justice.
It wasn’t a show that was for everyone, and mental health professionals weighed in on the show and found it to be problematic for some audiences. A few months after it originally aired, the suicide scene was edited out and a warning was added to episodes to guide people on getting help if they were struggling themselves.
That’s the first reason this show shouldn’t have gone past the first season. “It became a show that was reliant on shock value, cramming in every possible thing that would warrant a warning before the show.” As much as I liked the show, I didn’t need the story to continue past the book.
The book had a clear ending, and future seasons took on a life of their own. Rather than allow the show to end with all of Hannah’s reasons being dealt with and her story being put to rest, the show left season one open ended with so many things that never even happened in the book — like Alex Standall potentially killing himself — making future seasons a huge departure from the story.
That’s the second reason the show shouldn’t have gone past the first season. What’s really unfortunate about seasons two, three, and four of 13 Reasons Why is that the students become more obnoxious, the crimes become more severe, the show becomes more graphic.
And yet through it all, it’s forgettable. I couldn’t even tell you what happens in season two, other than the trial over Hannah’s life and death and Bryce Walker’s responsibility in all of it. The third season took yet another detour by focusing all its energy on Bryce and sort of trying to redeem him despite the fact that he rapes people and is an absolute assh*le?! After the absolute mess of the third season, there really, really shouldn’t have been a fourth season.
But alas, a fourth season we did get. Season four is just plain weird. Of the 10 episodes, I would say the first seven or eight feel like a straight-up horror movie. From the creepy music to horror-like cinematography and Clay’s mental instability, it feels like you’re living inside his head as he starts to break down.
- It feels absolutely nothing like where the show started in 2017 and with Asher’s book in 2007.
- It became a show that was reliant on shock value, cramming in every possible thing that would warrant a warning before the show.
- In season four alone, we had to deal with racism, police brutality, a school shooting, mental instability, and an AIDS-related death.
And I know these things are real-world problems, but to throw them all into one singular season of a show after already having dealt with suicide, rape, murder, and excessive underage drinking and drug use just feels like too much. As the show progressed and moved farther and farther away from the original story, it made me like the first season less because it felt tainted.
- I had similar feelings about Big Little Lies when the show got a second season that was far outside the book,
- In a similar fashion, the second season of that show tanked what was an incredibly well-done first season, but at least those showrunners didn’t pursue further seasons.
- Netflix, on the other hand, kept stringing viewers along for more seasons of 13 Reasons Why, and now as a viewer, I’m so far outside the heart-wrenching original story that I’m just angry-watching the show to find out how it ends so I can check off a box in my head.
I went into the fourth season with low expectations after seasons two and three, which admittedly made me despise it less than I expected, and though there were a few moments that I liked, I was just downright mad when Justin Foley was killed off in the end.
Netflix spent time over the past seasons building him back up into a respectable teenager on the verge of going to college and making something of himself, despite having a troubled upbringing and struggling to just make it through a day, only to have him die from AIDS-related complications in the end.
That ending was the nail in the coffin for me that this show absolutely and unequivocally should have ended after season one.
What is the most popular TV episode ever?
Most watched broadcasts of all time – Of the 30 most-watched broadcasts, 22 are Super Bowls, four are news events, three are primetime television programs, and one is a non-football related sports event. Though the Apollo 11 Moon landing is the most watched television event in American history, it is considered a news event, meaning that Fox ‘s live telecast of Super Bowl LVII in 2023 holds the record for the largest average viewership of any live single network U.S.
- Television broadcast, with 115.1 million viewers.
- The most watched primetime programs (non Super Bowl related) are the finale of M*A*S*H in 1983 (106 million viewers), Roots (“Part VIII”), The Day After (tied at 100 million), Leon Spinks vs.
- Muhammad Ali II (90 million), Dallas ‘s 1980 ” Who Done It ” episode (83.6 million), the 1993 series finale of Cheers (80.5 million), the February 23, 1994, broadcast of ladies’ singles figure skating at the 1994 Winter Olympics (78.8 million), and the Seinfeld finale in 1998 (76.3 million).
The following is the list of the all-time most watched television broadcasts in the United States by average viewership, according to the Nielsen ratings : Denotes news event Denotes primetime program Denotes non-football related sports event
| Rank | Broadcast | Average viewers (in millions) | Date | Network(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Apollo 11 Moon landing | 125–150 | 20 July 1969 | multiple |
| 2 | Super Bowl LVII | 115.1 | 12 February 2023 | Fox |
| 3 | Super Bowl XLIX | 114.4 | 1 February 2015 | NBC |
| 4 | Super Bowl LVI | 112.3 | 13 February 2022 | NBC |
| 5 | Super Bowl XLVIII | 112.2 | 2 February 2014 | Fox |
| 6 | Super Bowl 50 | 111.9 | 7 February 2016 | CBS |
| 7 | Super Bowl XLVI | 111.3 | 5 February 2012 | NBC |
| Super Bowl LI | 5 February 2017 | Fox | ||
| 9 | Super Bowl XLV | 111.0 | 6 February 2011 | Fox |
| 10 | Richard Nixon’s resignation speech | 110.0 | 8 August 1974 | multiple |
| 11 | Super Bowl XLVII | 108.7 | 3 February 2013 | CBS |
| 12 | Super Bowl XLIV | 106.5 | 7 February 2010 | CBS |
| 13 | M*A*S*H (” Goodbye, Farewell and Amen “) | 105.9 | 28 February 1983 | CBS |
| 14 | Super Bowl LII | 103.4 | 4 February 2018 | NBC |
| 15 | Super Bowl LIV | 100.4 | 2 February 2020 | Fox |
| 16 | Roots (” Part VIII “) | 100.0 | 30 January 1977 | ABC |
| The Day After | 20 November 1983 | |||
| 18 | Super Bowl XLIII | 98.7 | 1 February 2009 | NBC |
| 19 | Super Bowl LIII | 98.2 | 3 February 2019 | CBS |
| 20 | Super Bowl XLII | 97.4 | 3 February 2008 | Fox |
| 21 | Police pursuit of O.J. Simpson | 95.0 | 17 June 1994 | multiple |
| 22 | Super Bowl XXX | 94.1 | 28 January 1996 | NBC |
| 23 | Super Bowl XLI | 93.2 | 4 February 2007 | CBS |
| 24 | Super Bowl XX | 92.6 | 26 January 1986 | NBC |
| 25 | Super Bowl LV | 91.6 | 7 February 2021 | CBS |
| 26 | Super Bowl XXVII | 91.0 | 31 January 1993 | NBC |
| 27 | Super Bowl XL | 90.7 | 5 February 2006 | ABC |
| 28 | Leon Spinks vs. Muhammad Ali II | 90.0 | 15 September 1978 | ABC |
| 29 | Super Bowl XXVIII | 90.0 | 30 January 1994 | NBC |
| 30 | Disneyland Grand Opening | 90.0 | 17 July 1955 | ABC |
What is the most viewed episode in the world?
10 Friends – “The Last One” – 
Warner Bros. Television The finale of Friends is one of the most iconic and highly-watched TV episodes of all time. The beloved sitcom, which ran for 10 seasons, followed the lives of six friends living in New York City as they navigated their way through adulthood.
The finale, which aired in 2004, brought the series to a close in a way that was both satisfying and emotional for fans. The episode saw the friends say goodbye to the apartment that had been the show’s central location, and also dealt with the question of whether Ross and Rachel would finally get back together.
The episode was filled with nostalgia and sentimentality, and it was a fitting end to one of the most popular sitcoms of all time.
Did they take the scene of Hannah slitting her wrists out of 13 Reasons Why?
Two years after the premiere of 13 Reasons Why, Netflix has edited out the show’s controversial graphic suicide scene. Netflix confirmed to the Hollywood Reporter on July 14 that it had removed the scene, featured in the finale of the show’s first season, releasing statements from both the network and members of the 13 Reasons Why creative team.
As we prepare to launch season three later this summer, we’ve been mindful about the ongoing debate around the show,” a spokesperson told THR. “So on the advice of medical experts, including Dr. Christine Moutier, chief medical officer at the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, we’ve decided with creator Brian Yorkey and the producers to edit the scene in which Hannah takes her own life from season one.” The original cut of the infamous 13 Reasons Why episode depicted Hannah, the show’s troubled heroine, getting into a bathtub and slitting her wrists with a razor, with the camera lingering so that every detail of what she was doing was clear.
The new version, however, has removed those details. Now, we instead see Hannah looking into the bathroom mirror before climbing into the bathtub, and then move from that sequence directly to the moment in which her mother finds her dead body. “Our creative intent in portraying the ugly, painful reality of suicide in such graphic detail in season one was to tell the truth about the horror of such an act, and make sure no one would ever wish to emulate it,” Yorkey said in a statement to THR, adding that ” one scene is more important than the life of the show, and its message that we must take better care of each other.
We believe this edit will help the show do the most good for the most people while mitigating any risk for especially vulnerable young viewers.” The Hollywood Reporter adds that Netflix is expected to work toward ensuring the scene does not appear on third-party platforms, like YouTube or Twitter — essentially wiping it fully from existence.
This is the most conclusive response Netflix has offered to the ongoing criticism surrounding the suicide scene. After the first wave of backlash against the show in 2017, Netflix announced that it would increase its trigger warnings. Originally, it offered written warnings before the three episodes that showed Hannah’s suicide and graphic rape scenes, as well as a separate, 30-minute PSA episode starring the cast and crew of the show, entitled Beyond the Reasons.
What happened in the broomstick scene?
’13 Reasons Why’ finale Beth Dubber/Netflix Warning: This story contains spoilers from the second season of 13 Reasons Why. In the first season of 13 Reasons Why, nothing was held back. In the finale, Hannah’s ( Katherine Langford ) suicide scene was very graphic, causing a great deal of outrage from fans and parents who felt that it wasn’t necessary to show.
- On Friday, May 18, the second season was released on Netflix and fans are saying the same thing – this time about an assault scene.
- After going away to receive help for his anger, Tyler ( Devin Druid ) returned to school with a new outlook.
- However, Monty ( Timothy Granaderos ) wasn’t over everything Tyler had done – basically, doing everything he could to get Bryce ( Justin Prentice ) to pay for assaulting women.
Bryce told Monty to get over it, but he wouldn’t listen. Instead, he and his friends jumped Tyler in the bathroom, slamming his head against the mirror and the sink and pushing his face into the toilet multiple times. Monty then sexually assaulted him using a wooden broomstick, leaving Tyler bleeding out. ’13 Reasons Why’ finale Beth Dubber/Netflix To say the scene was graphic would be an understatement. But was it necessary? After binging, some fans took to Twitter to share their feelings, claiming it was more about “shock value” than anything else. “There was absolutely no need for that scene with Tyler in the last episode.
- Why did that need to be written in.13 Reasons Why is problematic and that’s that,” one viewer wrote.
- Another added, “AFTER THAT BRUTAL SCENE WITH THE MOP AND TYLER, THIS SHOW NEEDS TO BE CANCELLED.
- Obviously the people behind this show only gives a f—k about shock value and not about rape or suicide.” Others felt it was important.
“I agree that the Tyler’s moment in episode 13 was hard to watch. but what happened is true and some people go through that s—t, so if you think that was too much to watch, take a second and think what others have felt and no one talks about it,” one fan wrote,
- Another added : “All of y’all are pissed because Tyler got sodimized in with a broom #13ReasonsWhy2,
- But this happened at my former school to a kid I know.
- Multiple football players raped a 15-year-old boy with a broomstick.
- I heard about it I almost threw up.
- 13ReasonsWhy needed to show this.” Selena Gomez, who is a producer on the show, spoke out following the first season of the show, responding to the fans who thought the suicide scene was too intense.
“We wanted to do it justice and, yeah, going to come no matter what,” she told the Associated Press last year. “It’s not an easy subject to talk about, but I’m very fortunate with how it’s doing.” None of the writers have spoken out about the season 2 finale.
In the beginning of season 2, the cast members take turn reading a warning message. ” 13 Reasons Why is a fictional series that tackles tough, real-world issues, taking a look at sexual assault, substance abuse, suicide, and more,” the warning says. “By shedding a light on these difficult topics, we hope our show can help viewers start a conversation.
But if you are struggling with these issues yourself, this series may not be right for you or you may want to watch it with a trusted adult. And if you ever feel you need someone to talk with, reach out to a parent, a friend, a school counselor, or an adult you trust, call a local helpline, or go to 13ReasonsWhy.info,
Because the minute you start talking about it, it gets easier.” Specific episodes, including the finale, had an additional warning before the opening credits about sexual assault and drug use.13 Reasons Why season 2 is currently streaming on Netflix, Sign up for Us Weekly’s free, daily newsletter and never miss breaking news or exclusive stories about your favorite celebrities, TV shows and more! If you or someone you know is contemplating suicide, call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-8255.
For access to all our exclusive celebrity videos and interviews – Subscribe on YouTube!
What did Justin Foley do to Hannah in 13 Reasons Why?
Justin Foley
| has declared that this article has stopped in time, and any or all information on it may be, Help improve this article by checking and updating its info wherever necessary And now time resumes! |
table>
Justy (by Jessica, Montgomery and Bryce) Mr. Foley (by Mr. Porter) Jacket (by Dee) High School Student (formerly) Vagrant (formerly) Bartender/Waiter (formerly) Bullying (formerly), Shooting up heroin.Spending quality time with Hannah Baker (formerly),Spending quality time with Jessica Davis.
| ” | Justin : This is beyond just us now. This is the whole school. If we fall, you go down with us. Clay : Maybe I don’t care. Justin : Maybe you should. | „ |
| ~ Justin threatening Clay. |
table>
Justin Foley is the secondary antagonist of the 2007 novel Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher. He is a major character in the 2017 Netflix adaptation of the same name, serving as the secondary antagonist of the first season and a major character in the following seasons.
- Justin is a part of Hannah Baker’s and the subject of Hannah Baker’s first and ninth tapes from her list of reasons why she commits suicide.
- Justin and Hannah dated in the beginning of the school year until Justin began spreading false rumors of him and Hannah hooking up on their first date when in actuality they only kissed a couple times.
This would result in a chain of events that leads to Hannah committing suicide. His second tape revealed that he allowed to rape Jessica the night of Jessica’s party and did nothing to stop him. Overall, Justin is responsible for Hannah’s suicide. He was portrayed by in the TV series.
Whose funeral is at the end of 13 Reasons Why?
Who died at the end of 13 Reasons Why season four? – The final season of 13 Reasons Why is structured around the funeral of one of the show’s characters, but it’s not until the finale that the identity of the deceased is revealed: Justin Foley ( Brandon Flynn ), Clay’s adopted brother.
- At the end of episode nine, after reconciling with his former girlfriend Jessica Davis ( Alisha Bao ) at the senior prom, Justin collapsed.
- As is revealed in the series finale, Justin had not only tested positive for HIV, but the virus had progressed to AIDS.
- Justin, who left his abusive home life at the end of season one, lived on the street throughout season two; during that time, he started using heroin and became a sex worker.) After a short time in the hospital, he eventually dies—but not before providing both Clay and Jessica with a chance to say goodbye.
Later, during his emotional funeral, a minister (played by Phylicia Rashad ) speaks to the show’s key characters and seemingly the audience itself to offer up a call-to-action for the future. “Justin Foley died of a disease that from its inception thrives in silence.
There are a number of such diseases, a number of ills that thrive when we are silent about them. Because we let our fears, our shame, our twisted moral codes keep us in silence as death stalks more children. I say, enough. Enough shifting blame. Enough pointing fingers. Enough confusing those who report the damage with those who cause it.” But that’s not the end of Justin in the 13 Reasons Why finale.
After the surviving characters graduate, Justin appears as a vision to Clay—which sets up the return of Hannah Baker for the first time since season two.
What was deleted from 13 Reasons Why?
For more than two years, Netflix faced a backlash for including a graphic suicide scene in the first season of its hit show “13 Reasons Why,” raising concerns about whether the teen drama’s contents may be harmful to young audiences. On Tuesday, the show announced the scene had been deleted.
“No one scene is more important than the life of the show, and its message that we must better take care of each other,” the show’s creator, Brian Yorkey, said in a statement shared to Twitter after midnight. “We believe this edit will help the show do the most good for the most people while mitigating any risk for especially vulnerable young viewers.” The fictional series, which premiered in March 2017 and is now on the cusp of a third season, includes raw portrayals of sensitive subjects such as teen suicide, sexual assault and substance abuse.
It is based on a young adult novel of the same name by Jay Asher. Much of the criticism, however, initially stemmed from a nearly three-minute-long scene in Season 1 that depicted the show’s main character, 17-year-old Hannah Baker, committing suicide.
The scene was originally part of the season finale and showed Hannah, played by actress Katherine Langford, taking a razor blade to her arm, screaming as blood poured from the cut. The camera then stayed on Hannah as she took her last breaths and reddish water spilled over the top of the tub. By early Tuesday, the gut-wrenching scene had already been removed from the episode.
Now, viewers only see Hannah breathing shakily as she stares into a bathroom mirror and the aftermath of her parents finding her body. The decision to edit the episode was made in part due to feedback from experts such as Christine Moutier, chief medical officer at the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention (AFSP), Netflix said in a statement on Twitter.
“We’ve heard from many young people that 13 Reasons Why encouraged them to start conversations about difficult issues like depression and suicide and get help — often for the first time,” the statement said. “As we prepare to launch Season 3 later this summer, we’ve been mindful about the ongoing debate around the show.” AFSP did not respond to a request for comment early Tuesday, but issued a joint statement with other similar organizations and mental health professionals supporting the edit and calling it a “positive change,” Variety reported,
The Parents Television Council, an entertainment media watchdog group that has demanded Netflix pull the show in the past, said it also applauded the “responsible decision.” “Netflix has finally acknowledged the harmful impact that explicit content is capable of inflicting on children,” said President Tim Winter, adding that the streaming platform should now “redouble its efforts to protect children from harmful content.” “Netflix has finally acknowledged the harmful impact that explicit content is capable of inflicting on children.
While we applaud Netflix for making this responsible decision, we call on Netflix to redouble its efforts to protect children from harmful content.” – @TimWinterPTC https://t.co/MDi5yMZbRn — Parents Television Council (@ThePTC) July 16, 2019 When Season 1 of “13 Reasons Why” premiered, it quickly made some parents, educators and suicide prevention experts uneasy, The Washington Post’s Bethonie Butler reported,
While the show may have good intentions, its premise that Hannah can still tell her story even after death through audiotapes glamorizes suicide, Dan Reidenberg, executive director of Suicide Awareness Voices of Education, told The Post. Studies have also found dramatic images or graphic descriptions of suicides may contribute to the suicide contagion effect.
- Young people are not that great at separating fiction from reality,” Reidenberg said.
- That gets even harder to do when you’re struggling with thoughts.” After people started watching the show, Internet searches about suicide increased, according to an October 2017 study from JAMA Internal Medicine.
“Our analyses suggest ’13 Reasons Why,’ in its present form, has both increased suicidal awareness while unintentionally increasing suicidal ideation,” the study’s authors wrote. “The most rising queries focused on suicidal ideation. For instance, ‘how to commit suicide’, ‘commit suicide’ and ‘how to kill yourself’ were all significantly higher.” That same year, suicide was also the second leading cause of death for people between the ages of 10 and 24, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
A recent study funded by the National Institute of Mental Health suggested that “13 Reasons Why” was associated with a 28.9 percent increase in suicide rates among people in the United States aged 10 to 17 in the month after the first episode aired. “The number of deaths by suicide recorded in April 2017 was greater than the number seen in any single month during the five-year period examined by the researchers,” the April study said.
In response to the backlash, Netflix has taken steps meant to ensure that the show’s content doesn’t harm its impressionable teenage audience. The streaming giant commissioned a global study from Northwestern University’s Center on Media and Human Development to better understand how viewers were affected.
- The study, which was released in March 2018, resulted in changes to the series such as the addition of extensive trigger warnings and more resources intended to help parents discuss the difficult themes with their children.
- But despite the warnings and a custom video featuring the show’s stars that accompanied the debut of Season 2 last year, the series was again met with backlash.
This time, critics took issue with how the show handled a school shooter and its decision to include a brutal rape scene. “Our North Star is always to try to tell these stories of these characters in the most truthful way we can, and to follow them in directions that are taking us to issues and themes that are in the lives of kids today,” Yorkey told the Hollywood Reporter in 2018.
Season 2’s “stories are in the show because that’s where our characters led us, and they’re stories and themes that we felt were really vital to the experience of young people today.” On Tuesday, Yorkey offered a similar explanation for the now-deleted suicide scene. “It was our hope, in making 13 Reasons Why into a television show, to tell a story that would help young viewers feel seen and heard, and encourage empathy in all who viewed it, much as the bestselling book did before us,” he said in the statement.
“Our creative intent in portraying the ugly, painful reality of suicide in such graphic detail in Season 1 was to tell the truth about the horror of such an act, and make sure no one would ever wish to emulate it.” More from Morning Mix:
Did they remove Tyler bathroom scene?
23 August 2019, 17:29 Timothy Granaderos, who plays Monty, says the 13 Reasons Why season 2 Tyler bathroom assault scene made him feel sick when he watched it back.13 Reasons Why’s run on Netflix has not been without its controversies. Season 1 was criticised for its less than masterful handling of Hannah’s graphic suicide scene and many felt season 2 also crossed a line with Monty’s controversial bathroom assault of Tyler Down (Devin Druid). Montgomery De La Cruz 13 Reasons Why. Picture: Netflix “I didn’t expect it, but I got kind of nauseous, and my stomach was churning after watching it,” he told the publication. “To be honest, I would expect that reaction from people.” The Tyler Down bathroom rape scene was one of season 2’s most controversial moments. Tyler Down bathroom assault scene in 13 Reasons Why season 2. Picture: Netflix Last year, Tyler Down actor Devin Druid addressed the scene in an interview with ET. “It’s not something that people think about a lot,” he said. “And then as a male character, what does that feel like for you in a society where you’re told this shouldn’t happen to you, and not that it should happen to anybody, but that this can’t happen to you, but it does, what does that do to you on a mental level as well as physically obviously an enormous amount of pain.” Season 3 of 13 Reasons Why is officially out now and Timothy Granaderos promises that this series “feels like a different show”.
Is 13 Reasons Why season 2 connected to season 1?
Do You Need to Watch ’13 Reasons Why’ Season 1 to Watch Season 2? is a teen drama on Netflix that tells the story of (Katherine Langford) and the reasons why she committed suicide. Hannah leaves behind 13 tapes, each one dedicated to a person who somehow contributed to her choosing to end her life.
- The show unfolds like a mystery, with each tape filling in more details about Hannah’s life and death.
- While the first season of 13 Reasons Why is based on the of the same name by, Season 2 of the series is going past the events of the book to continue the story.
- The second season will focus on the fallout of Hannah’s suicide and the lawsuit her parents are bringing against the school.
And with the new season also comes a new mystery revolving around the appearance of mysterious polaroids targeting some of the students testifying. While fans may be tempted to jump into Season 2 to see what all the fuss is about, it is a much better experience watching Season 1 of 13 Reasons Why first.
Is season 2 of 13 Reasons Why about Hannah?
Katherine Langford as Hannah Baker For more on season 2 of 13 Reasons Why — and the potential third season — pick up the upcoming issue of Entertainment Weekly, on newsstands Friday. Don’t forget to subscribe for more exclusive interviews and photos, only in EW, Spoiler alert: This post contains plot from season 2 of 13 Reasons Why,
- When Netflix announced that 13 Reasons Why would get a second season, the obvious question was how Hannah Baker, who died in the season 1 finale, would stick around.
- And now, with the release of season 2, fans have an answer : Not only is Hannah Baker in flashbacks, but she’s also in present day.
- Call her a ghost, call her a figment of Clay’s imagination, but she’s there, and only Clay can talk to her.
“We were making a bold choice in having Hannah appear in scenes with Clay in the present day,” showrunner Brian Yorkey tells EW. “I don’t necessarily like to put a word on it — some people believe in ghosts, some people think maybe Clay is cracking up.
But where it came from is my mom died a few years ago and we were very close — I was very much a mama’s boy — and I have conversations with her still to this day. I don’t think she’s necessarily here in the room with me, but I also don’t think that she’s not. “We were interested in Clay’s grieving process and his state of mind as a pretty typical American young man,” Yorkey continues.
“One of our big themes was recovery and healing and finding ways to move on with your life and we wanted to see Clay get to a point where he could say, ‘I love you Hannah, but I’m letting you go.’ We wanted to see what that process looked like and that led us to giving him the ability to have conversations with her to express his grief but also his anger at her for what she did and really be able to work through that.” 13 Reasons Why season 2 is currently streaming on Netflix. 13 Reasons Why Based on the 2007 novel by Jay Asher, the Netflix drama follows a teen named Clay who attempts to figure out what led his classmate and crush Hannah to take her own life.
| type |
TV Show |
| seasons |
4 |
| rating | |
| genre |
Drama Mystery |
| creator |
Brian Yorkey |
| network |
Netflix |
| stream service |
Netflix |
What happened between season 1 and 2 of 13 Reasons Why?
Hannah’s Parents Split Up Olivia (Kate Walsh) wants to fight Liberty High for their role in Hannah’s death, but Andy (Brian d’Arcy James) just wants to put this chapter behind him. Ultimately, they separate, and Andy moves in with his new girlfriend Valerie, whom we learn later he was dating before Hannah died.
Is 13 Reasons Why season 2 based on the book?
This article is about the television series. For the novel it is based on, see Thirteen Reasons Why,
| 13 Reasons Why | |
|---|---|
| Also known as | Thirteen Reasons Why |
| Genre |
|
| Based on | Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher |
| Developed by | Brian Yorkey |
| Starring |
|
| Narrated by |
|
| Opening theme | “Oh in This World of Dread, Carry On” by Eskmo |
| Composer | Eskmo |
| Country of origin | United States |
| Original language | English |
| No. of seasons | 4 |
| No. of episodes | 49 ( list of episodes ) |
| Production | |
| Executive producers |
|
| Producer |
Joseph Incaprera |
| Cinematography | Andrij Parekh |
| Editor | Leo Trombetta |
| Camera setup | Single-camera |
| Running time | 49–98 minutes |
| Production companies |
|
| Release | |
| Original network | Netflix |
| Picture format | 4K ( Ultra HD ) |
| Audio format | Dolby Digital 5.1 |
| Original release | March 31, 2017 – June 5, 2020 |
13 Reasons Why is an American teen drama television series developed for Netflix by Brian Yorkey and based on the 2007 novel Thirteen Reasons Why by author Jay Asher, The series revolves around high school student Clay Jensen ( Dylan Minnette ) and the aftermath of the suicide of fellow student Hannah Baker ( Katherine Langford ).
Before her death, she leaves behind a box of cassette tapes in which she details the reasons why she chose to end her life as well as the people she believes are responsible for her death. Through its various storylines, the show explores and depicts a wide range of social issues affecting modern youth.
The series was produced by July Moon Productions, Kicked to the Curb Productions, That Kid Ed Productions, Anonymous Content and Paramount Television, with Yorkey and Diana Son serving as showrunners for the first season, and Yorkey for the rest of the series.
Dylan Minnette and Katherine Langford star as Clay Jensen and Hannah Baker, respectively, alongside an ensemble cast. A film from Universal Pictures based on Thirteen Reasons Why began development in February 2011, with Selena Gomez set to star as Hannah, before being shelved in favor of a television series and Netflix ordering an adaptation as a limited series in October 2015, with Gomez instead serving as an executive producer.
The first season was released on Netflix on March 31, 2017. It received positive reviews from critics and audiences, who praised its themes, emotional weight, subject matter, character development and acting, particularly the performances of Minnette and Langford.
- For her performance, Langford received a Golden Globe Award nomination for Best Actress – Television Series Drama,
- However, its graphic depiction of issues such as suicide, sexual assault, bullying, and rape (along with other mature content) prompted concerns from mental health professionals.
- In response, Netflix added a warning card in March 2018 that plays at the start of each episode warning viewers about the themes of each season.
In July 2019, Netflix edited out the suicide scene in the first season’s final episode. In May 2017, Netflix renewed 13 Reasons Why for a second season due to the success of the initial 13 episodes; the second season was released on May 18, 2018, and was met with generally negative critical reviews.
- Coinciding with the release of the second season, Netflix released a video with the cast that cautioned viewers on some of the topics covered in the show and provided a support website with crisis numbers for people affected by depression, anxiety and other mental health issues.
- A third season was ordered in June 2018 and was released on August 23, 2019.
In August 2019, the series was renewed for a fourth and final season, which premiered on June 5, 2020.